Baldwin County cold case remembered
RYAN DEZEMBER • Mobile Press-Register • June 22, 2009
FOLEY, Ala. — Fifty years ago, a 4-year-old named Danny Barter, camping with family on the banks of Perdido Bay, vanished, prompting perhaps the largest manhunt in Baldwin County’s history and launching a case that would become one of the area’s coldest.
Advertisement
On Saturday three generations of Barters, many of whom made trips of 12 and 14 hours from their homes in Texas, convened in south Baldwin County to rekindle interest in the case and remember their lost brother, cousin, uncle.
As vexing as Danny’s disappearance is, his family holds out hope that he is alive today, unaware of his true identity.
“This is not an ending for us,” Mike Barter, Danny’s younger brother, told about 50 people gathered Saturday evening in the conference room of a Foley hotel. “This is just to remind people that it’s been 50 years, and if it takes another 50 years, there will be some of us working on it.”
After brief remarks by investigators, family members and Lynn Ruess, an Auburn woman who has privately researched the case and worked to bring attention to it for the past three years, the group traveled to the site of Danny Barter’s disappearance to hold a vigil.
A house, the owners of which allowed the Barter family to convene in the yard Saturday night, now sits on the location.
But on June 19, 1959, the site was a vacant patch in a fairly remote spot north of the U.S. 98 bridge into Florida. The Barter family owned the property and used it as a bayside retreat.
On the day he went missing, Danny was camping with his parents, Maxine and Paul Barter, both of whom are now dead; three of his seven siblings; an uncle and two cousins.
About 9:45 a.m., as the group prepared for a fishing trip, they realized that Danny, last seen barefoot, wearing a pair of gray boxer shorts and drinking from a bottle of soda, was gone.
The search for the brown-haired boy with a fear of the water began at the beach, but no footprints were found leading to the water.
By afternoon, 150 people — sheriff’s deputies, firefighters, enlisted men from Pensacola Naval Air Station — had joined the search.
(2 of 2)
Before nightfall, Navy pilots gave family members hope when they reported that no body had surfaced on the bay.
The next day saw 500 people come out to look for the little boy from Mobile.
Mounted deputies combed wooded areas. Strings of men walked shoulder-to-shoulder through nearby Lillian Swamp, scouring sinkholes and thickets. Boats dragged nets along the bay’s floor.
One the third day, the search grew more desperate. Alligators were gutted in a search of human remains.
Dynamite, aimed at dislodging a three-foot-tall body from the bottom, was dropped into the bay.
An abduction theory grew as bloodhounds brought to the scene tracked Danny’s scent from the campground to a nearby road, where a Nehi soda bottle, like the one he’d been drinking, was found.
Because of the persistence of Danny’s siblings, investigators reopened the case last year, working under the assumption that it was a kidnapping.
“For the FBI, child abductions are without a doubt the most important cases we work,” Joseph Fierro, the assistant special agent in charge of the FBI’s Mobile field office, told the Barters on Saturday. “If that had been the case when Danny disappeared, there may have been a different outcome.”
One of investigators’ main strategies over the past 18 months has been to publicize the case, be it in the local media or national crime shows, hoping that doing so might shake loose a fresh tip or perhaps even a recollection by Danny Barter himself, who would now be 54.
“Since we reopened the case 1½ years ago many, many leads have come up, and none of them have panned out,” Capt. Steve Arthur of the Baldwin County Sheriff’s Office said.
Arthur, addressing the Robertsdale Rotary Club last week, said investigators thought they had a breakthrough six months ago after a Milwaukee man committed suicide, and his therapist told police that the deceased man may have been a pedophile who had committed crimes.
A search of the dead man’s home revealed a photograph of a young boy dated 1959, but investigators in Wisconsin eventually discovered that the photo was not of Danny Barter and that the Milwaukee man purported to be a psychic and had solicited the photograph from the family of another missing person in an effort to solve the mystery.
On Saturday Arthur said the Barter family’s persistence and optimism over five decades is something he has not seen before in his 34 years career in law enforcement.
“If I live to be 100,” he said, “I won’t forget this case or the family’s dedication.”
http://www.pnj.com/article/20090622/NEWS01/90622021/1006/RSS01