Haleigh Saga: Troubled family hopes for her safe return
But an investigator says they can't "get a straight line" on their probe.
By Dana Treen Story updated at 9:38 AM on Saturday, May. 16, 2009
Early in the search for Haleigh Cummings, Putnam County detectives posted a family tree on their office wall to keep track of and explore any intertwined connections in the case.
A little more than three months later, investigators said they are no closer to finding the 5-year-old girl whose bright smile adorns buttons, posters, T-shirts and the hearts of a community.
In the same time, troubles that follow her family have left investigators sensing someone connected to them knows more.
"There is a lot going on with this family," said Dick Schauland, spokesman for the Putnam County Sheriff's Office. "We still can't get a straight line with what is going on with this thing."
Since Haleigh was reported missing from a Satsuma mobile home early Feb. 10, national attention to the case has brought in more than 4,000 leads. Detectives continue to sift through the tips, but come back to the all-important timeline in an attempt to define what was going on in the days before Haleigh vanished.
Still missing
The Putnam County kindergartner has been missing since she went to bed the night of Feb. 9.
Haleigh Cummings: The kindergartner at Browning Pearce Elementary School disappeared from her bed sometime between 10 p.m. Feb. 9 and 3 a.m. Feb. 10. Her father's girlfriend said she woke up to find her missing from the same room where they were sleeping with Haleigh's younger brother.
A screen door propped open with a brick was one of the only clues detectives found in days of intense searching on land and water.
Family players
Ronald Cummings:
Haleigh's 25-year-old father has a history of minor drug arrests and has shown flashes of violent behavior. On the 911 call, he was convinced someone abducted his daughter and vowed to kill them. He has been living with his grandmother after losing his job for not making arrangements to keep it, though his attorneys say he was told he would be reinstated.
Court affidavits in a 2005 custody case with Haleigh's mother, Crystal Sheffield, accuse him of abuse and that "his chosen lifestyle and illegal business actions pose a severe risk to the children."
Cummings has another child with Sheffield and a disabled toddler son with another woman. He was never married to either of his children's mothers. He married underage Misty Croslin with permission from her parents a little more than a month after Haleigh's disappearance.
Misty Croslin Cummings:
Croslin was 16 when she went to live with Cummings last year and was the one who reported Haleigh missing. On the weekend before Haleigh disappeared, Croslin was reported to have had a tryst with a 28-year-old while partying after a fight with Cummings. Detectives say she has changed her story about the disappearance in 10 interviews.
She and Cummings were married the day before traveling to New York for a live appearance on "Today" to discuss Haleigh's disappearance.
Crystal Sheffield:
Haleigh's 23-year-old mother began living with Cummings when she was 14 and was pregnant with Haleigh at 17. Sheffield has been separated from Cummings since 2005. She has not had custody of their daughter or son, Ronald Jr., since then and now has a second daughter. Lack of employment, previous drug use and several missed doctor's appointments for Haleigh were discussed in the custody papers. She owes Cummings thousands in child support.
At the Haleigh Bug Center, a small roadside outpost in southern Putnam County that uses a nickname for her missing daughter, Sheffield and her supporters attempt to keep the public focused on the case. When she is not there, Sheffield is at home in Baker County with her younger daughter, where she lives with her fiancee, who is her stepbrother, and his two children. Family connections
Hank Croslin:
He and his wife gave legal consent for their daughter's marriage to Cummings. Weeks later, he filed a complaint with the Putnam County Sheriff's Office to say his new son-in-law gave him a pill that was supposed to help with pain from a serious traffic accident but instead put him in a coma. In the incident report, he said Cummings often gave him pain pills.
He later denied that Cummings gave him pills at any time or that he feared his son-in-law, according to a news release from Cummings' attorney.
Joseph Overstreet:
A Croslin family relative from Tennessee, Overstreet was accused of stealing a gun from Ronald Cummings soon after arriving for a visit. He left Putnam County the day Haleigh disappeared. His cousin, Croslin, said Overstreet had "messed" with her when both were young. Investigators cleared Overstreet of involvement in the disappearance.
Amber Brooks:
She is the 20-year-old mother of Cummings' other son, Jordan, who is disabled. Brooks has been arrested on drug charges, including attempting to smuggle cocaine into jail following an arrest in April at a Palatka motel known for drug activity. She also was charged in January with drug possession.
Croslin was a baby-sitter for Brooks and met Cummings after telling him Brooks was leaving her with the baby for long periods.
Street connections
Kristina "Nay Nay" Prevatt:
A friend of Brooks, she was arrested with her at the Palatka motel in April and charged with attempting to smuggle drugs into the jail. Four people were arrested on drug possession charges in that case.
Prevatt also is an acquaintance of Croslin and was with her the weekend before Haleigh disappeared. The two spent time partying with Greg "White Boy" Page. She caused a stir when a radio station reported investigators had a break in the case because she was in custody. The Sheriff's Office said there was no connection.
Greg "White Boy" Page:
On the weekend before Haleigh disappeared during a night of partying and drugs, Page said he hooked up with Croslin with the help of Prevatt after her fight with Cummings. Page, who recently said he hadn't talked with her since, also has several drug arrests and was sentenced to six months in jail in 2008 for selling pot.
Outside connections
Kim Picazio:
A South Florida attorney who is representing Sheffield for free, Picazio has made no bones about her determination to have Ronald Jr. taken from his father. She has met with the state Department of Children and Families, and the agency is investigating her allegations. Picazio also is paying for running the Haleigh Bug Center and said she has rented a house in Putnam for use by staffers who come and go from South Florida. Picazio has sponsored an online site,
www.haleighbug.com, that offers a link for those who have tips in the case.
William "Cobra" Staubs:
A private investigator and bounty hunter, Staubs is an associate of Picazio's and is conducting much of her investigation. He once bailed Prevatt out of jail and returned her for breaking conditions of her release.
Early in the case, he was charged with false imprisonment after accosting Daniel Snodgrass, a Satsuma man who was free on bail on a sex charge involving children.
Greg Kimball and T. Jerry Snider:
The Palatka attorneys are representing Cummings, also for free. The firm has used news releases to refute accusations that Cummings is an abusive father and created an online site,
www.findhaleighnow.com, to support a continued search for Haleigh.
This report contains material gathered from police reports, court records and interviews, as well as from a video interview with Greg Page by Art Harris of The Bald Truth on artharris.com. Harris is a former CNN investigative correspondent.
HAVE YOU SEEN HALEIGH?
Call Crime Stoppers of Northeast Florida, (888) 277-8477 (277-TIPS). She is 3 feet tall and weighs about 40 pounds. She has long, blondish-brown hair and brown eyes. She also has a birthmark on her left cheek.
Web sites
The father's:
www.findhaleighnow.com
The mother's:
www.haleighbug.com
dana.treen@jacksonville.com, (904) 359-4091
http://www.jacksonville.com/news/metro/2009-05-16/story/haleigh_saga_troubled_family_hopes_for_her_safe_return