View Full Version: IS ABUSE AN EXCUSE?

fromwhisperstor >>Inside the Mind Of… >>IS ABUSE AN EXCUSE?


<< Prev | Next >>

Chickadee- 03-16-2006
IS ABUSE AN EXCUSE?
Report of the American Psychological Association Presidential Task Force On Violence And The Family ISSUES AND DILEMMAS IN FAMILY VIOLENCE IS ABUSE AN EXCUSE? Generally people feel compassion for abuse victims, along with understanding and forgiveness for some of their undesirable behaviors, but often those attitudes conflict with the need to hold people personally accountable for their behavior. Are people not taking responsibility for their own behavior and using abuse as an excuse? Some say that society has begun to blame prior abuse for all reprehensible behavior, thus creating a victim-culture which rewards remaining a victim rather than healing and getting on with life. They point to the proliferation of television talk show hosts who interview victims of all kinds of abuse as encouraging the victim-culture attitude, as well as to legal defenses using evidence of child or adult abuse as another example. People who are abused suffer many consequences, and in some cases those consequences may bring harm to other people. While most abused persons do not become violent, the absence of treatment or other helpful interventions for victims of abuse appears to be related to their later involvement in violence or other destructive behaviors. Treating patterns of violence and victimization can be extremely difficult, requiring multidimensional approaches to change motivation and behavior, and careful, sustained follow-up. A long-term view, then, calls for a commitment to providing ways for victims to resolve the negative feelings and patterns of behavior that often result from a history of abuse. After sufficient and appropriate assistance is provided, victims can be expected to seek help for themselves and to take individual responsibility for their own behavior. http://www.apa.org/pi/pii/familyvio/issue11.html

Gaia- 03-16-2006

No abuse is NOT an excuse. I was physically and sexually abused (not by the same person) but that in no way gives me the right to continue the cycle. In fact it makes me want to stop it all the more. I dont consider myself a victim of abuse. I am a survivor. Hating takes more energy than Im willing to waste. Yes, my abusers should be held accountable for thier actions and someday they will. I have no doubts whatsoever about that. Karma. But do I wallow in pity? No. I confronted my abusers and made my stand as an adult. They cant hurt me anymore and I wont allow them to hurt anyone else. Just because they are members of my family doesnt mean I wont call the cops on thier butts in a Philly minute. It stops here. I do not abuse my children and God help the person who dares to touch them. The burning flames of Hades will be chilly compared to what I will do. Abuse is not an excuse. Deal with it and stop it from happening to someone else. JMO

Chickadee- 03-17-2006
Feel same
I know so many survivors and they are not abusers. In fact they or their families are the main ones crying out for stronger change in the laws, prevention and support for victims programs. They understand better than most as they have walked the walk and know the pain of wrecked lives. Some victims may become abuser but it is not the majority and I said may due to the above artilce. Just my thoughts. Prevention of any type of child abuse will reduce incidents. We all must do our part for the children who are the adults of tomorrow. My Grand Daughter was sexual abused as a child and is not a abuser. I saw first hand the horror of child sexual abuse, she is 20 and still fighting the scars left. This experience made me become an advocate against abuse of any kind. Would like to say "off with their heads" but that would not be political correct .. so I did not say it.

Themis Eternal- 03-17-2006

"off with their heads" I never was one to be politically correct anyway. :twisted: While were at it Off with ALL Offending parts too(That includes hands)

Gaia- 03-17-2006

I am telling you people.......we need to bring back the FIRING SQUADS!!!! (i'm not 'p.c' either) :twisted:

Chickadee- 03-17-2006
I did say it
:D I did say "off with thier heads" .. now I will admit it. :D Oh yes the firing squad is needed < This gets my vote :evil:

Themis Eternal- 03-18-2006

Ya have to remember Chick on this board everyone has an opinion is allowed to express it without being attacked. As for being "pc" I personally think it's a load of crap. Whoever thought that one up should be first for the firing squad LOL. The only thing anyone should every be is honest. No matter what anyone thinks no one is wrong here. Can I get an amen!

Forumer™ is Voted #1 Free Forum Hosting provider
Build your own community today with the largest message board hosting company.