Man spared death penalty in murder of Curious George collaborator
By Nancy L. Othón | South Florida Sun-Sentinel
11:09 PM EDT, July 16, 2008
Vincent Puglisi was spared the death penalty Wednesday when a judge determined that his role in the death of Curious George collaborator Alan Shalleck in Boynton Beach was no greater than that of his co-defendant, who was already sentenced to life in prison.
A jury convicted Puglisi, 56, of first-degree murder and robbery with a deadly weapon last month. Puglisi gave up his right to have the same jury decide if he would face life in prison or death by lethal injection, opting to leave the decision in the judge's hands.
Circuit Judge Krista Marx said she had spent many hours reviewing the evidence in considering the issue of proportionality and concluded there was nothing to show Puglisi was more culpable for Shalleck's murder.
Puglisi and Rex Ditto, 32, planned to rob and kill Shalleck, a 76-year-old retiree who had sought out partners for sexual rendezvous at his home. Puglisi had known Shalleck for a year and brought Ditto to Shalleck's mobile home in February 2006.
Shalleck was stabbed at least 37 times and repeatedly beaten. His body was left wrapped in plastic garbage bags on his driveway.
Ditto strangled, clubbed and stabbed Shalleck until he died, prosecutors said, and Puglisi held a pillow over his head and robbed him of jewelry and a checkbook.
Assistant State Attorney Andy Slater told Marx that the murder never would have occurred had it not been for Puglisi, who set up the appointment with Shalleck, brought latex gloves and knew what the outcome would be.
"Mr. Puglisi is up close and personal and intimately involved" with the murder and Puglisi had the motive because he needed money, Slater said. "I think that Mr. Puglisi is a major participant in this homicide."
It's simplistic to say Ditto is more culpable because he was the "muscle" in the killing, Slater added.
Marx rejected the argument and allowed the prosecution only to present testimony about the impact of Shalleck's death. Shalleck's oldest son, David Shalleck, described to Marx how his father, branding himself as "Gramps," read books to hundreds of Palm Beach County children at schools, libraries, bookstores and day care centers.
He credited his father's innovation for bringing the beloved Curious George character to television and spoke of the fact Shalleck was robbed of the opportunity to read to his own grandchildren.
"This is clearly a loss in this community," Shalleck said.
Before sentencing, Marx addressed the Shalleck family and acknowledged their loss, saying the death must have been "the biggest heartbreak of your life."
She then turned to Puglisi and told him that while the brutality of the crime was unspeakable and that he appeared indifferent throughout the trial, she was bound by law to sentence him to life in prison.
Nancy Othón can be reached at
nothon@sun-sentinel.com or 561-243-6633.
http://www.sun-sentinel.com/news/local/palmbeach/sfl-flppuglisi0717pnjul17,0,7006958.story?track=rss